发邮件向老师请教问题Treatment Effect Model的问题

苹果/安卓/wp
积分 1022, 距离下一级还需 353 积分
权限: 自定义头衔, 签名中使用图片, 隐身
道具: 彩虹炫, 涂鸦板, 雷达卡, 热点灯, 金钱卡, 显身卡, 匿名卡, 抢沙发下一级可获得
权限: 设置帖子权限道具: 提升卡
购买后可立即获得
权限: 隐身
道具: 金钱卡, 彩虹炫, 雷达卡, 热点灯, 涂鸦板
无聊签到天数: 1361 天连续签到: 10 天[LV.10]以坛为家III
& && &&&小弟最近在阅读Treatment effect的一些文章,无奈才疏学浅,对于模型有几点疑问,欢迎各位高手指教:
15:27:53 上传
& & 请问这个MTE在实证研究中具体该怎么计算?U1i U0i Us具体怎么计算?非常感谢。
载入中......
&nbsp&nbsp|
&nbsp&nbsp|
&nbsp&nbsp|
&nbsp&nbsp|
&nbsp&nbsp|
&nbsp&nbsp|
如有投资本站或合作意向,请联系(010-);
邮箱:service@pinggu.org
投诉或不良信息处理:(010-)
论坛法律顾问:王进律师Treatment Effect97-第5页
上亿文档资料,等你来发现
Treatment Effect97-5
StataTechnicalBulletin21;Options;sensvar;specvar#speci?esthevalue;#speci?esthecon?dencelev;fromshowingtheiterationl;reportstheestimatedcoef?;#,#,and#specifythede?nit;isthedefault.;
StataTechnicalBulletin21
specvar#speci?esthevalueorthenameofthesensitivityvariable.Sensitivityshouldbebetween0and1.#speci?esthevalueorthenameofthespeci?cityvariable.Speci?cityshouldbebetween0and1.
#speci?esthecon?dencelevel,inpercent,forcon?denceintervals.Thedefaultis
fromshowingtheiterationlog.orassetby.speci?esthattheHuber/White/sandwichestimatorofvarianceistobeusedinplaceofthetraditionalcalculation.prevents
reportstheestimatedcoef?cientsinsteadofoddsratios.Thisoptionaffectshowresultsaredisplayed,nothowtheyareestimated.maybespeci?edatestimationorwhenredisplayingpreviouslyestimatedresults.
#,#,and#specifythede?nitionofconvergence.
isthedefault.
Convergenceisdeclaredwhen
fortwoconsecutiveEMsteps.Inaddition,iterationstopswhen
“convergencenotachieved”arepresented.Thereturncodeisstillsetto0.;inthatcase,resultsalongwiththemessage
Optionsforpredict
,thedefault,calculatestheprobabilityofapositiveoutcome.
calculatesthelinearprediction.
calculatesthestandarderrorofthelinearprediction.
numbersthecovariatepatterns―observationswiththesamecovariatepatternhavethesame.Observationsnotusedinestimationhavethepredictionsettomissing.The“?rst”covariatepatternisnumbered1,thesecond2,andsoon.Remarks
Traditionallogitorlogisticregressionassumesthattheoutcomevariableismeasuredwithouterror.Insomestudies,however,theoutcomevariableisnotmeasuredperfectly.Thiscanoccur,forexample,whenusingadiagnostictesthavingsensitivityand/orspeci?citylowerthan100%.Theresultingmisclassi?cationcanleadtobiasinthecoef?cientsestimatedandrelatedstatistics(Copeland,etal.1977).
MagderandHughes(1997)proposedanEMalgorithmthatincorporatesthevaluesofthesensitivityandspeci?cityoftheclassi?cationtestintotheestimationofthelogisticparameters.Theyshowedthatinthepresenceofmisclassi?cation,theirprocedureproducedunbiasedestimatesofboththecoef?cientsandtheirvariances.ItisthisEMalgorithmthatwehaveimplementedin.Notethatwhensensitivityandspeci?cityarebothsettoone,andproducethesameestimates.
Tosetto,etal.(1999)conductedacaseCcontrolstudytodeterminetheimportanceoftheprothrombingenealleleG20210Aasariskfactorinvenousthromboembolism(VTE).Thestudyconsistedof116VTEpatientsand232healthyindividualsascertainedrandomlyfromawellde?nedpopulation.Foreachsubjectinthestudy,theyobtainedinformationregardingpreviousdiagnosisofVTEusingasurveytoolwithanestimatedsensitivityof71.3%andspeci?cityof98.9%.
Eachsubjectinthestudywasalsotypedattheprothrombinlocus.Nohomozygouscarriersofthemutatedallele(G20210A)werefound.Thirteen(3.7%)subjectswereheterozygousforthemutationandtheremaining335subjectsdidnothavethemutation.
Inourdata,indicateswhetherthepatienthasbeendiagnosedwithVTE,and
mutation.Herearetheresultsfrom:whethertheindividualhasthe
22StataTechnicalBulletinSTB-55andthosefromincorporatingthesensitivityandspeci?city:
NeithermodelprovidesevidencesupportingthehypothesisofanassociationbetweenthemutatedalleleandVTE.Notethat
islarger―furtherfromthenull―thanthatreportedbystandardlogisticregression,althoughtheoddsratioreportedby
itsstandarderrorislarger,re?ectingtheaddeduncertaintyabouttheoutcomevariable.Thisisaknownnamely,theEMalgorithmtypicallyproduceslargeroddsratiosandlargervariances.
SavedResults
numberofobservations
loglikelihood
loglikelihood,constant-onlymodel
modeldegreesoffreedom
pseudo-squared
nameofdependentvariable
;typeofmodeltest
coef?cientvector
varianceCcovariancematrixoftheestimators
marksestimationsampleFunctions
MethodsandFormulas
Let1ifindividualtrulyhastheoutcomeofinterest(diseased)and0otherwise(nondiseased).Letifindividualisclassi?edashavingtheoutcomeand0otherwise.Assumethatistheprobabilitythatthethindividualtrulyhasthe
and1covariatevector.Thenifindividualisclassi?edashavingtheconditionbeingstudiedgiventhevaluesof
whereisa1coef?cientvectortobeestimated,and
StataTechnicalBulletin23
TheEMalgorithmbeginsby?rstsetting
expectationstep.toanarbitraryvalueandcomputingforeachobservation.Thisisthe
Thedataarethenduplicatedandeachobservationincludedtwice,oncewiththeoutcomevariablesetto1andanother
iftheoutcomevariableiswiththeoutcomesettozero.Aweightedlogisticregressionmodelis?ttedwithweightsequalto
ifitiszero.Thisconstitutesthemaximizationstep.1and
Thenew’sobtainedfromthe?ttedlogisticmodelareusedtocalculatenew
isdeclared.’sandtheprocessrepeateduntilconvergence
References
Copeland,K.T.,H.Checkoway,A.J.Michael,andR.H.Holbrook.1977.Biasduetomisclassi?cationintheestimationofrelativerisk.American
JournalofEpidemiology105:488C495.
Magder,L.S.andJ.P.Hughes.1997.Logisticregressionwhentheoutcomeismeasuredwithuncertainty.AmericanJournalofEpidemiology146:
Tosetto,A.,E.Missiaglia,M.Frezzato,andF.Rodeghiero.1999.TheVITAproject:prothrombinG20210Amutationandvenousthromboembolism
inthegeneralpopulation.ThrombHaemost82:.
sg140TheGumbelquantileplotandatestforchoiceofextrememodels
ManuelG.Scotto,UniversityofLisbon,arima@mail.telepac.pt
Abstract:Somestatisticaltoolsforexploratorydataanalysisarepresented.TheGumbelquantileplotisdescribedasaninformal
waytotestiftheGumbeldistributionprovidesagood?tfordata.Furthermore,weincludeamethodofstatisticalchoiceamongthethreeextremevaluedistributions.
Keywords:Generalizedextremevaluedistribution,hypothesistesting,Gumbelquantileplot.
varnameexprange
Introduction
Themaingoalofthisworkisindealingwiththestatisticalchoiceofextrememodels.Thisisessentialinapplicationswheretheattentionisfocusedatrarelyoccurringevents,suchasanannualmaximal?oodexceedingdykes,oraseasonalminimaltemperaturebelowthecriticalvalueforcropproduction.Werestrictourselvestotheone-dimensionalcaseandstartwithadiscussionoftheproblem.
Letbeindependentandidenticallydistributedrandomvariableswithunderlyingmarginaldistributiongivenbywhichisthewell-knowngeneralizedextremevaluedistribution(GEV).Theparametersandarethelocationandscaleparametersrespectivelyandistheshapeparameterandmaybeusedtomodelawiderangeoftailbehaviors.Therearethreeparticularformsofcorrespondingto0(Fr′echetdistribution),0(Weibulldistribution),and0beinginterpreted
0,widelycalledtheGumbeldistribution.WeusetheGumbelquantileplot(GQP)andthestatistic?rstasthelimitas
introducedbyGumbelanddevelopedbyTiagodeOliveiraandGomes(1984),hereafterreferredtoasOG.foraquickstatisticalchoicebetweentheextrememodels.
ThequantileplotfortheGumbeldistribution
Probabilityplottingpapersarecommonlyusedtoassess,inaninformalway,whetherasamplecomesfromaparticulardistribution.FortheGumbeldistribution,thequantilefunctionisgivenby
whichleadstosocalleddoublelogarithmicplotting.Tothisend,we?rsttaketheorderedsampleandplot
versus,where1istheclassicalplottingposition.IftheGumbeldistributionprovidesagood?ttoourdata,thentheGQPshouldlookroughlylinear.Furthermore,bothFr′echetandWeibullmodelscanalsobevalidatedby
24StataTechnicalBulletinSTB-55meansoftheGQP.IftheplothasadownsideconcavitywecanassumeaFr′echetmodelwhereasanupsideconcavityindicatesaWeibullmodel.Finally,notethat
Usinglinearregression,quickestimatesfor
estimatorscanbeobtainedbymeansoftheandcanbededucedfromtheslopeandtheintercept.MaximumlikelihoodcommandintroducedinScottoandTobias(1998).
Statisticalchoicebetweentheextrememodels
StatisticalchoiceamongtheextrememodelsgivesacentralandpreeminentpositiontotheGumbeldistributionduetothesimplicityofinferencesassociatedwiththisdistribution.WepresentatestforH:intheGEVmodel.Weconsiderthestatistic,
whichislocationanddispersion-parameterfree.UnderthevalidityofH,itwasshownbyOGthatthereexist0andsuchthat.Onechoiceis2and22.OGproposedasimpledecidingruleinordertodecideachoose0anddecidefortheGumbeldistributionwhen,fortheFr′echetdistributionwhen,andfortheWeibulldistributionwhen.Thevaluesofandcorrespondingtotheusualsigni?cancearegiveninthetablebelow.
0.001-1.....001
WeappliedboththeGQPandthestatisticaltestdescribedabove,totheannualmaximumsealevelsinVenicedatasetduringtheperiod1981C82(Smith1986).
ThisgivesrisetothegraphinFigure1.
(Graphonnextpage)
StataTechnicalBulletin25
Figure1.References
Scotto,M.G.andA.Tobias.1998.TechnicalBulletinReprints,vol.Smith,R.L.1986.ExtremevalueTiagodeOliveira,J.andM.I.J.TiagodeOliveira.Dordrecht:sg141Abstract:ThisarticledescribesestimatesatreatmenteffectsmodelconsiderstheconditionalontwosetsofeffectsmodelandcompletehowthecommandisusedKeywords:Probit,endogenousSyntax
Basicsyntax
depvarvarlistFullsyntaxformaximumdepvarvarlist#Fullsyntaxfortwo-stepdepvarvarlists,ands,s,isspeci?ed.sharesthefeaturesofall
三亿文库包含各类专业文献、幼儿教育、小学教育、高等教育、行业资料、文学作品欣赏、生活休闲娱乐、应用写作文书、Treatment Effect97等内容。 
 Steel surface treatment effect meets the application requirements_林学_农林牧渔_专业资料。Steel surface treatment effect meets the application requirements, ...  Effects of long-term PPI treatment_临床医学_医药卫生_专业资料。Eur J Clin Invest. ):380-6. doi: 10.1111/j.10.02419.x...  4.2 Most important symptoms and effects, both acute and delayed 主要症状和...4.3 Indication of any immediate medical attention and special treatment needed...  THESIS STATEMENT In this particular research, an analysis has been adopted with regard to the evaluation of the causes, effects and treatment of Anorexia ...   Effect of Heat Treatment Process on Properties of 1000 MPa Ultra-High Strength Steel_机械/仪表_工程科技_专业资料。Two types of steel, C-Mn-Cr-Mo-B...   Effect of cellulase treatment on the extent of post-finishing and dyeing of cotton fabrics N.A.Ibrahim a,H.M.Fahmy a,T.M.Hassan b,?,Z.E....  干预效应模型(treatment effect model)与倾向值匹配法有如下共同的特征 _A______ A. 都使用选择的残差项对结果做精细分析 B. 都使用匹配以弱化干扰变量的影响...   Effect of Heat Treatment on Niobium Segregation翻译_材料科学_工程科技_专业资料。中英文热处理对激光熔覆 IN718 合金涂层铌偏析的影响摘要:IN718合金涂层是由...请教连老师2sls和处理效应模型
我的图书馆
请教连老师2sls和处理效应模型
&本帖最后由 arlionn 于
20:30 编辑
& &2SLS 是一类估计方法的统称,也即我们平时所言的两阶段最小二乘法,我想细节和过程不必赘述。
& &Treatment Effect Model 可以视为一个特殊的内生性问题,其特征是内生变量为 0/1 变量。因此,第一阶段的回归不能再用 OLS,而是使用了 Logit 或 Probit,并以此为基础得到所谓的 hazard ratio;在第二步的回归中,在原有模型设定的基础上,加入 Hazard ratio 来调整内生性导致的偏误(详情 help treatreg,查看电子说明书中有关 Method 部分的说明)。
& &所以,你提到的文献中的处理方法,从严格意义上来讲,是不对的。至于二者之间的偏差有多大,由于没有做过相关的模拟,也没有看到相关的文献,目前还不得而知。
*==============Appendix===================
& && &&&*--------
& && &&&*-4.2.1.2&&处理效应 Treatment effect
& && && & *-& &Y = X*b1 + D*b2 + U
& && && & *& & D is 0/1 变量, 内生
& && && & *
& && && & *-本质:一个内生的 0/1 变量 (一个特殊的 IV 问题)
& && && && &
& && && & * 例 1:Y=ROA, D=是否实施股权激励(Yes=1, No=0)
& && && & * 例 2:Y=Wage,D=是否大学毕业(Yes=1, No=0)
& && && & *
& && && & * 内生性问题的根源:业绩好的公司更倾向于实施股权激励
& && && & *& && && && && && & 能力强的人更可能顺利读完大学
& && &*-其它例子:
& && && & *-&&是否读博士?
& && && & *-&&是否建立政治关联?(游说, 贿赂, 当选人大代表等)
& && && & *-&&是否实施多元化经营, 交叉上市, 兼并收购?&&
&&*-------------------
&&*-4.2.3 处理效应模型&&Treatment Effect Model
& & *--------
& & *-4.2.3.1&&二元模型设定
& && &help treatreg& &// Also see | Manual: [R] treatreg
& && &shellout "$R\Stata_Treatreg.pdf"&&
& &*-Primary regression equation:
& &*& && &y_j = X_j*b1 + T_j*b2 + e_j& &&&(1)&&e_j~N(0,sigma^2)
& &*-Treatment equation
& &*& && &T_j* = W_j*gamma + u_j& && && & (2)&&Latent variable
& &*& && && && && && && && && && && && && && & u_j~N(0,1)
& &*-Decision rule:
& &*& && && && &{ 1&&if (T_j*&0)
& &*& && &T_j = {& && && && && && && &Note: T_j 是可以观察到的
& &*& && && && &{ 0&&otherwise
& &*& &Corr(e_j, u_j) = rho& &// 内生性的根源
& &*- rho&0,表明 OLS 低估了 T_j 对 y_j 的边际影响;
& &*- rho&0,表明 OLS 高估了 T_j 对 y_j 的边际影响;
& & *--------
& & *-4.2.3.2&&估计方法
& && &*-最大似然估计 (Maxlikelihood Estimation, MLE)
& && && && &*-基于二元联合正态分布函数
& && &*-两步法 (Two-step Estimation)
& && && &&&
& && && && &*-Step1: Probit (Treat Equation) --& Prob(Z=1)
& && && && &*& && &&&probit T w
& && && && &*& && && &&&{ H = normden(wb)/normal(wb)& && &&&if T=1
& && && && &*& &Hazard: {
& && && && &*& && && &&&{ H = -normalden(wb)/(1-normal(wb)) if T=0
& && && && && &
& && && && &*-Step2: reg y X z H&&// regression Equation 中加入 hazard
TA的最新馆藏
喜欢该文的人也喜欢

我要回帖

更多关于 请教别人问题的邮件 的文章

 

随机推荐